Newswire

February Market Insights: Trump’s Shadow

large-Market-Insights_LinkedIn_February-2024

Echoes of History and Financial Markets in a Post-Pandemic World

Download this PDF here.

As we enter a presidential election year in the U.S., financial markets are resonating with historical echoes. One can particularly recognize the rise of populism after the Civil War, which parallels today’s socio-political dynamics. This comparison challenges the conventional wisdom about investing in a world that is constantly evolving. Concomitantly, there are parallels to the post-Second World War era, notably the extreme levels of debt which rival only today. As the war ended and life got back to normal, a growth scare and deflation resulted. Hence my thesis that our transition period out of COVID-19 has all the earmarks of a transitional period of secular stagnation and deflation.

Graph-1-1024x722

The U.S. in the mid-19th century, marked by the Civil War, saw President Abraham Lincoln make significant economic decisions that influenced the nation’s trajectory. His choice to fund the Union’s war efforts by introducing a currency not backed by gold, known as greenbacks, mirrors the U.S. Federal Reserve’s recent monetary policies. In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, the Federal Reserve cut interest rates and implemented measures akin to Lincoln’s, thereby injecting capital into the economy.

Post-Civil War, Lincoln’s recall of greenbacks to contract money supply echoes the Federal Reserve’s quantitative tightening (QT) and subsequent rate hikes following the pandemic, intended to stabilize the economy. Yet, as history shows, both actions resulted in economic downturns, with slowdowns and deflationary periods highlighting the cyclical nature of such interventions. History reveals the global economy is headed for deflation, similar to the post-Civil War and post-Second World War eras.

The economic uncertainty that followed the Civil War also fostered a populist movement, seeking the backing of the U.S. dollar with both gold and silver. This same populist sentiment has resurfaced in modern times, a response to the disenfranchisement and inequality that many feel today.
Graph-2-1024x764

The Wizard of Oz has often been interpreted as an allegory for the economic and political issues of the late 1800s, particularly the debate over bimetallism.

Bimetallism is a monetary system which allowed for the unrestricted coinage of gold and silver, set at a fixed ratio, to circulate as legal tender. The Yellow Brick Road represents the gold standard, and Dorothy’s silver slippers (changed to ruby in the film adaptation) symbolize the silver standard, as advocated in Former U.S. Secretary of State William Jennings Bryan’s “Cross of Gold” speech. In this speech, he passionately argued for bimetallism, using the metaphor of a gold cross to criticize the strict adherence to the gold standard, which Bryan felt was crucifying the working class and farmers on a “cross of gold.” However, the system was fraught with challenges, such as Gresham’s Law,1 and
became central to the political debate of the 19th century, culminating in the 1896 U.S. presidential election. Today, we find a parallel in central banks who have overtightened, causing hardship for many, and the call for reflation and an end to deflationary risks.

A Global Reflationary Cycle

Looking ahead to 2024-25, a global reflation episode seems imminent, with economic policies and populist measures likely to favour secular growth. Drawing lessons from the period following the 2008 Global Financial Crisis, the NASDAQ-100 and Bitcoin are poised to lead this trend. Nevertheless, as the economy shows signs of bottoming later in 2024, cyclical sectors are expected to catch up, benefiting from the broader economic recovery. To be clear, I’m not forecasting a ‘V’ shaped recovery, my base case is that we are entering a period of secular stagnation and deflation. With debt to gross domestic product (GDP) at levels not seen since the Second World War, investors should anticipate a growth and deflation scare similar to the late 1940s.

Historically, markets have rallied in anticipation of a recovery as the future is discounted. A rally into the summer followed by a correction into the election would not be surprising. If historical patterns are followed, a more substantial rally into the 2026 midterm elections, with an S&P 500 target of 6000, is my forecast. Therefore, investors should consider historical patterns when developing their strategies, with an emphasis on cyclical stocks as recovery signs begin to materialize.

Investment Approaches in a PreRecovery Phase

With the Federal Reserve’s funds rate projected to stay below 2.5% until late 2025, investors have an opportunity to engage in reflation trades. These trades typically align with the populist push for economic growth, indicating that now is a strategic time to invest in sectors that may benefit from lower borrowing costs and economic stimulus. My base case is not a return to the zero bound for interest rates—but to be clear, with extreme levels of debt and a rapid transition into a digital economy, coupled with the two largest economies in the world going through generational structural adjustments, investors need to keep an open mind.

Market Timing and Portfolio Management

As we anticipate the economic bottoming in the latter half of 2024, savvy investors should be prepared to adjust their market entry for cyclical investments. The anticipated rally into the summer offers a window to capitalize on early recovery optimism, per historical trends. However, it is equally important to be vigilant and ready for potential post-election market pullbacks, with an eye toward additional volatility as we approach the 2026 midterm election year. My target for the S&P 500 for 2024 is 5400.

What Should Investors Do?

While the narrative of “this time is different” often appears during unique historical moments, the underlying patterns of history suggest otherwise. The lessons from the postCivil War era, with its economic and political upheavals, provide a valuable framework for understanding today’s market challenges and opportunities.

Principally, they highlight that the dynamics of markets and politics are often cyclical, recuring in patterns that, while not identical, rhyme enough to offer guidance. By recognizing this in economies and markets, and focusing on sectors which benefit from these cycles, investors can craft well-informed strategies that echo successful practices from the past and adapt to the distinct contours of the current era. This balanced approach is key to thriving in the populist era of the mid-2020s. Investors should be alert for the expected reflationary trend and be astute in timing their purchases of growth and cyclical stocks to balance their portfolios.

So, “is this time different?” The answer is a resounding “no.” The patterns of history are manifesting once again, suggesting that insightful investors will benefit from studying the past to prepare for the future.

Recent Posts

January Market Insights: Is There Something Rotten In The State Of Canada?

In this sequel to Is There Something Rotten in the State of Canada? we delve further into the complex web of monetary and fiscal policies that seem at odds with one another, evoking the drama of a Shakespearean play. The phantom of secular stagnation and deflation is likely to haunt us once again in 2024. To quote Macbeth, “By the pricking of my thumbs, something wicked this way comes.” This chilling sentiment resonates when considering the future of Canada’s economy.

Read More »

Quarterly Investment Insight – Winter 2024

It has been 45 years since BusinessWeek declared the “Death of Equities,” warning that rampant inflation was “destroying the stock market” and “to regard the death of equities as a near-permanent condition.”1 These dramatic prognostications haven’t subsided over time, likely because negative news is more appealing. When one news website decided to report exclusively good news for a day, it lost two-thirds of its readership.2 Our brains are hardwired to react more strongly to negative information.

Read More »

December Market Insights: 2024 Forecast

Ray Kurzweil, computer scientist and futurist, once said, “The past is over; the present is fleeting; we live in the future.” This sentiment echoes through our current moment as we stand on the threshold of an era defined by technological advancement, navigating a myriad of complex challenges and opportunities.

Read More »

2023 Federal Fall Economic Statement

On November 21, 2023, Canada’s Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Finance, the Honourable Chrystia Freeland, delivered the 2023 Fall Economic Statement (FES 2023), a mid-fiscal year update that was narrower in focus than previous economic statements.

Read More »

November Market Insights: Riding The Bull In The Midst Of Chaos

In the investment world, volatility and uncertainty often reign, evoking a sense of unease. Remembering the call for 3000 on the S&P 500 Index in late 2022, the recent correction at 4600 might seem unnerving. Yet, like the hopeful message in Steely Dan’s song Any Major Dude Will Tell You, we should maintain our resilience, knowing that things will eventually fall together again.

Read More »

The opinions contained herein are the opinions of the author and readers should not assume they reflect the opinions or recommendations of Wellington-Altus Private Wealth. Assumptions, opinions and information constitute the author’s judgement as of the date this material and subject to change without notice. We do not warrant the completeness or accuracy of this material, and it should not be relied upon as such. Before acting on any recommendation, you should consider whether it is suitable for your particular circumstances and, if necessary, seek professional advice. Graphs and charts are used for illustrative purposes only and do not reflect future values or future performance of any investment. The information does not provide financial, legal, tax or investment advice. Particular investment, tax, or trading strategies should be evaluated relative to each individual’s objectives and risk tolerance. All third party products and services referred to or advertised in this presentation are sold by the company or organization named. While these products or services may serve as valuable aids to the independent investor, WAPW does not specifically endorse any of these products or services. The third party products and services referred to, or advertised in this presentation, are available as a convenience to its customers only, and WAPW is not liable for any claims, losses or damages however arising out of any purchase or use of third party products or services. All insurance products and services are offered by life licensed advisors of Wellington-Altus. Wellington-Altus Private Wealth Inc. is a member of the Canadian Investor Protection Fund and the Investment Industry Regulatory Organization of Canada. All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.